Comcast, the FCC, and Me

Editor’s Note: This story was written by Dan Sokol about his experience with Comcast.

Some Background…

Comcast is my ISP. Like most of us in the US we have no real choice if we want fast internet in our homes.

Prior to 2011 my Comcast services included was ‘triple play’. I had internet, VoIP, and the default TV tier (no pay TV services, just the local channels). Sometime around September of 2011, when Comcast ended analog TV service and encrypted the base tier (you had to pay for a TV decoder box), I cancelled the TV service and the VoIP service. (I switched my home phone to MagicJack, but that’s a whole other story.)

In other words, the only Comcast service on my account was the internet.

When I made this change I had to swap out the Comcast rented ‘special’ VoIP modem and return it to Comcast. Comcast provided a box and shipping label to return the old modem. The new modem had the same $8/mo rental fee.

Naturally I checked the billing after the changeover to make sure everything was correct. (For the record, my monthly bill is paid thru my banks ‘Bill Pay’ service. All I do is approve the amount. If the billing amount is the same as the previous month I pay it w/o question. I dont look thru the monthly bill (a PDF) which is only available on the Comcast website.)

FYI, Comcast only allows you to see the previous 12 months of billing on the website.

end of background…

Sometime around April of this year, Comcast sent out an email informing it’s users that the monthly modem rental was being raised to $10/mo. So I expected my bill to increase by $2.

Imagine my surprise when my bill went up $4, not $2.

It seems that Comcast was billing me for 2 modems and had been doing so for years. (This double billing started sometime AFTER they removed the second modem from my bill back in 2011.)

I called Comcast customer support. You probably already know how long and unsatisfying that call was. I spent about 2 hours on the call. Was handed off twice. The customer rep could not see my billing any further back then 1 year.

The bottom line … FU. It’s your fault for not looking at your bill. Here’s $20, that’s all we’re allowed to give you. So sorry.

I told them that I calculated they owed me about $400 and that I would recover another way. I then proceeded to change my monthly internet tier from the top tier (105/12Mbs – $125/mo) to one of the middle tiers (60/4Mbs – $65/mo), thereby saving about ^60/mo.

I also went out an bought my own DOCSIS3 modem, something I should have done years ago.

That should have been the end of it. File under: “It’s Comcast, what did you expect?”

But then this appeared in one of my RSS feeds—>

https://consumercomplaints.fcc.gov/hc/en-us

The FCC is now taking complaints about COMCAST. MWAHAHAhahaha….

I followed the link to the Internet Complaint page.

My was surprised at how straightforward the page was and how easy it was to file the complaint.

Screen Shot 2015-06-26 at 2.26.43 PM

I filed the form with the FCC on June 22nd. This is the response I got from the FCC the next day.

———— ———— ————

Hi Daniel, June 24, 2015

Your Ticket No. 358465 was served on Comcast Cable Communications on Jun 24 for its review and response.

Comcast Cable Communications will likely contact you in an effort to resolve your issue.

A response is due to the FCC no later than 30 days from today. Comcast Cable Communications will respond to you directly by postal mail.

Thank you for your complaint and help in furthering the FCC’s mission on behalf of consumers.

———— ———— ————

Today is June 26th.

This morning I got a call from Comcast.

  1. An actual apology – The billing error was our fault. (Our software blah blah blah…)

  2. It happened in September 2011 after the Modem was returned.

  3. We owe you $385 and will credit your account by that much.

  4. We will lower your monthly bill by $20/mo for the next 12 months as part of our apology.

I was speechless. They asked me if I had any other issues and couldnt answer. My brain was thinking in Martian (What? What! What?).

In summary, I’m very surprised at the speed at which the FCC and Comcast dealt with this. (Maybe I was just the first one to file with the FCC and the rest of the country doesnt know about the site.)

Of course Comcast does have 12 months to screw this up. I’ll let you know 😉

Dan Sokol – 26 June 2015



13 thoughts on “Comcast, the FCC, and Me”

  1. You can also contact your state PUC to lodge a complaint.

    FWIW, I have an open complaint with AT&T and got zero response….

  2. Please do follow up on this and let us know how well Comcast executed on its promises.

  3. Clearly, this is just an example of how out of control the FCC really is. We have to stop this problem NOW and abolish the FCC entirely.

    How dare they get between a company and the people they steal from.

  4. So far, so good. This months’ bill has the discount and the credit is shown in the account.

    DS

  5. This is awesome and timely for me. I had all kinds of problems just recently where Comcast discontinued the package I had (I was grandfathered) and replaced it with an IDENTICAL package but at a lower price. They refused to let me sign up for the new, lower-priced but identical package. Seriously. Exact same service just a lower price.

    I was told they were charging me more “because they could.” And that was that.

    Ultimately after enough complaining they offered a 12mo promotional rate on my current legacy package but in 12mo that will just get jacked up again and I’ll go through this whole painful process all over. I only wanted the new package at the regular, lower price. No promotion, nothing special. They refused.

    I just filed my complaint with the FCC thanks to this article and I’ll let you know how it goes!

  6. My Comcast service is excellent. I blame it on two things:

    1) There is an actual Comcast store within a few miles of my home. When I’ve had to deal with billing issues, I walk in.

  7. I beg to suggest that your successful resolution with Comcast was ONLY due to FCC oversight. Which is why the big telecoms are furiously lobbying Congress to MURDER the FCC, or if not strip it of it’s enforcement authority.

  8. I used to live in a region that has both Verizon FIOS and Cablevision’s Optimum Online. Due to actual competition there was downward pressure on rate increases, constant improvement in service, and both companies raised their legendarily awful customer service games to something resembling human interaction.

    Competition, imagine that.

    And yes, I am in a Comcast area now. There have been a few bumps…

  9. Every one of those “end big government” wing-nuts needs to see this article. This is a perfect example of what happens Federal agencies remember that “…for the People” line, and how wrong Ronnie was (see: https://youtu.be/xhYJS80MgYA)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *