Steven Levy on Becoming Steve Jobs

Today is the day. Becoming Steve Jobs is now available for purchase and download.

Steven Levy, author of a number of excellent books on technology and on Apple, got his hands on a preview copy and had some interesting things to say. His review is worth reading, but I found his take on the new book vs the Walter Isaacson book particularly interesting:

In my view, Cook’s dismissal of Isaacson’s book as just a sloppy rehash is somewhat over the top. I came to Isaacson’s book with a lot of knowledge about Steve Jobs, yet I learned many new details from over 40 interviews Jobs gave to Isaacson, as well from some interviews Isaacson won because Jobs prevailed on people to cooperate with the book. No matter what one thinks of Isaacson’s book, it is absolutely permeated, as is appropriate, with the voice of its subject. In addition, no one is claiming that Isaacson fabricated material.

Instead, the complaint is that Isaacson over-emphasized Jobs’s unattractive qualities and failed to present a rounded picture that corresponded with the reality of those closest to him. Schlender and Tetzeli attempt to remedy that in two ways. First, they give plenty of room for people on the wrong side of Jobs’s bad behavior to contextualize it. Second, they present a contrast between the young Jobs, whose misdeeds often arose from a self-indulgence or a flailing indecisiveness, and the mature Jobs, who not only channeled his energies more successfully, but was able to develop rewarding adult relationships.

This is a tricky balancing act for the authors, as even to the last, Jobs could be a tough person to deal with. Towards the end of the book they spend a full chapter, titled “Blind Spots, Grudges and Sharp Elbows,” trying to deal with some of Jobs’ unsavory actions even after his touted maturation. There’s no getting around the fact that Jobs held grudges, was gleeful in apparently violating the labor laws banning corporate collusion in not hiring each other’s employees, and sometimes would throw formerly valued employees under the bus.

One of my favorite Steven Levy books, and one of his earlier efforts, Insanely Great is the inside story about the creation of the Mac. If you are a fan of Apple’s history, I think you’ll enjoy Insanely Great. It really captures the spark of creation that was the birth of the Macintosh.



2 thoughts on “Steven Levy on Becoming Steve Jobs”

  1. I forget who it was who said Levy should’ve been the one chosen for that first book instead of Isaacson. I tend to agree.

    After I finished reading Isaacson’s book, it went right into the Goodwill pile. Not because it was bad, but simply because it wasn’t a keeper. Annoying technical inaccuracies notwithstanding.

    It occurred to me that Isaacson was chosen for the project not because he understood the subject so well, but simply because he’d done some biographies. Not unlike the way many corporations choose their CEOs; finding a guy in the club who’s had the title before, not someone who might actually have expertise in a specific business sector.

    I’m looking forward to this book, but I may opt for the audio version instead of print.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *