David Carnoy, CNET:
Are they worth $549? Ultimately, that’s going to be up to you to determine. All I can do is describe my experience using them and let you know that they’re excellent (though not perfect) headphones, with top-notch sound, rock-solid wireless connectivity and noise canceling that’s arguably a touch better than what you find on competing models at the high end.
This is a great read. Anecdotal, but very up front about what’s fact and what’s opinion.
A few details:
This review is based on several days with the headphones. I’m still evaluating battery life and wired audio performance (among other things), which may or may not alter the final rating.
And:
The first thing you notice when you open the box is that their build quality is like nothing that’s out there in the $300 to $400 range. OK, there’s some stuff that’s close: The Bowers and Wilkins PX7 (down to $340 from its list price of $400) is sturdily built with an eye-catching design. I also like Sennheiser’s Momentum 3 for its build quality (down to $280 from its list price of $400). Master & Dynamic’s MW65, currently on sale for $400 (it lists for $500), is also unique-looking and made of premium materials. All those models feature strong sound quality but fall a little short on noise-canceling performance.
The Sony WH-1000XM4 get a lot of love for their noise cancellation and sound, and they are much cheaper (under $300). But the build quality is night and day different, the Sony’s made of mostly plastic and the AirPods Max made of high grade metals and soft fabrics and meshes. I’ll post a few videos a bit later this morning that will drive this point home.
Side-by-side, the Sony WH-1000XM4 are workmanlike in terms of build and the AirPods Max are luxury goods.
For heavy headphones they’re surprisingly comfortable, but I don’t expect that they’ll be super comfy for everyone, particularly those with neck problems. Personally, I thought It’d be nice if they were 20% lighter, but the way the headband is designed, with its mesh canopy, it takes a good amount of pressure off the top of your head.
The weight is a thing, so think about this before you buy. But if the weight is an issue for you, Apple does make it very easy to return any of their products, the AirPods Max included.
Their almost gel-like memory-foam earpads also stand out. They adhere magnetically to cover Apple’s 40mm custom drivers and have a fabric covering, which makes them more breathable than your typical leather or faux leather earpads like those found on the Sony WH-1000XM4. As a result, your ears steam up less in warmer environments.
Luxury goods.
The AirPods Max do sound impressive, like high-end headphones, with tight bass, natural mids, crisp highs and a wide soundstage for a closed-back headphone.
And:
Apple’s intention with the AirPods Max is to serve up a “high-end” audio experience or at least an approximation of one. The problem, of course, is serious audiophiles tend not to bother with wireless Bluetooth headphones or noise-canceling headphones. Bluetooth streaming has gotten better and better over the years and noise canceling doesn’t impact the sound nearly as much as it once did. But to get the most accurate, pure sound, which is what high-end headphones are all ultimately about, wired headphones coupled with a properly amplified source that plays lossless audio is going to get you to the real promised land.
I’m looking forward to reviews that take the time to use these wired with lossless audio. Those reviews are surely coming.
What you get with the AirPods Max is just clearer, more refined sound and basically no distortion at higher volumes — note that while they play loud, they don’t play incredibly loud. I’m not ready to say that the sound quite measures up to what you get from a pair of very high-end wired headphones, say something with a planar magnetic driver (one of Hifiman’s cans, for instance, the best of which are open back and leak sound). But it’s certainly a level up in terms of clarity from the Sony and Bose.
If the high price hasn’t turned you away, as I said before, you can order a pair to audition. If they don’t live up to the price, return them.